I got a PM from someone so here is the response in public. Listen, I have not lied about a thing and have no reason to. They are the closest shop to me a I would love nothing more than to be happy with them. Keep in mind, that I also have NOTHING to gain from relaying my experience. In fact, with people like you getting so personal about it, I can see why people are reluctant to post ALL experiences - good and bad. The simple fact is that their service has been inconsistent and I want people to know that. For you, as a third party who was not involved at all, to accuse me IS WHAT IS UNCOOL. The dent I pointed out when I took the rim in, was a MUCH smaller ding that was right on the seem of the rim (on the same side as the big dent). I never saw the huge dent, which, when I went to pick the rims up they pointed out at that time. They did NOT point that out when I dropped the rim off which you would expect them to do. When I picked the rim up and they then pointed it out, yes, I was extremely surprised, skeptical and frustrated. I initially thought that it happened at the shop because I try to pay close attention to my equipment and feel that I would have seen that especially considering I caught the one that was much smaller not too far from the huge one. While there is still some doubt in my mind, after thinking about it I realized that it is way, way more likely that the dent happened on a ride and that I just missed it. I never brought it up to them again and that is why I never brought that issue up in my post and why it really is not relevant. Yes, they did not charge me for that wheel and it was appreciated, however, you would think again, that it would be pointed out when I dropped it off or maybe even a phone call when they found it would have been warranted. What is relevant is that the front rim did not come back true, and as I mentioned in my post, is not the first time I have been less than happy with their tech service.
Sorry if YOU feel I have done something wrong but this is the truth. And like I said in my post, I know a lot of people are happy with them and that is fine. That is just what happened to me like it or not.